Approving a second supplier is a separate decision
A buyer may have a working supplier relationship and still have a reason to assess another machine shop. The need might involve peak demand, a new part, or a desire to avoid relying on one supplier for all delivery capacity.
A publication by NIST’s Manufacturing Extension Partnership describes adding a second source as a way to increase supply options and manage supply risk. This does not mean every buyer should split every part between two suppliers. Source: NIST MEP, second sourcing.
A machine shop’s first question is therefore where a second supplier might be needed. “We can make the same thing more cheaply” does not yet explain how the buyer’s production continuity or introduction of a new part would become easier.
Start with one real task
A good first step is small enough to assess but representative enough to show whether the intended delivery can succeed. An easy test piece does not demonstrate the ability to manufacture a difficult production part if the material, geometry or requirements change substantially.
Ask the buyer to identify the part or defined operation used for the assessment. Establish whether the aim is backup-supplier approval, a recurring share of orders or delivery for one project. Each requires capacity in a different way.
Agree acceptance criteria before manufacturing
A trial order is a poor test if you only learn after delivery what the buyer wanted to check. Before the order, review the drawing revision, material, acceptable delivery scope and who will make the approval decision.
Record separately what will be measured on every part and what will be checked on, for example, the first article. Choose the measurement method to suit the requirement; a calliper alone cannot verify every dimension or geometric requirement. If external measurement is needed, include its responsibility, timing and cost in the plan.
| Topic | Decision to record |
|---|---|
| Technical information | Drawing, revision, material and any deviations. |
| Evidence | Characteristics to inspect, measurement method and required documents. |
| Delivery | Batch, packaging, markings and delivery date. |
| Assessment | The buyer’s responsible person, feedback date and acceptance criteria. |
| Next steps | What approval enables and what still needs to be resolved. |
NIST’s supplier-selection guidance emphasises documenting manufacturing and inspections, and the ability to trace the source of a deviation. When assessing a trial order, consider how conformity is demonstrated alongside the part itself. Source: NIST MEP, supplier assessment.
Price the first batch and subsequent work separately
The first batch may include programming, making a fixture and more inspection work than usual. Make these costs visible. Otherwise, a small trial order can look like an expensive series delivery, or the machine shop ends up absorbing its cost.
If the work repeats, separate one-off preparation from the recurring batch price. Also agree fixture ownership, storage and any possible use by another manufacturer. Do not assume that whoever pays for the trial order automatically owns the tooling.
A trial-order discount must not rely on a supposedly certain production series that nobody has ordered. An estimated annual volume helps preparation, but a buyer’s forecast and a binding order are different information. State the quantity assumptions clearly in the quotation.
Deliver the agreed evidence with the parts
Before dispatch, check that the batch identification, drawing revision and documents refer to the same delivery. The buyer should be able to connect a measurement result to the correct part or batch at the level of traceability agreed.
If a deviation occurs during manufacturing, ask the buyer to decide on it before delivery. A small trial order does not permit a looser interpretation of the requirements. Obtain any concession in writing and keep it separate from the original requirement.
Agree a feedback discussion before dispatch. “Parts delivered” and “supplier approved for the next stage” are different states. If approval requires an assembly trial, there may be a wait between delivery and the decision.
Agree what happens after approval
A successful trial order can lead to approved backup-supplier status without an immediate series order. Find out what would trigger the next order. Is it exceeding a workload threshold, a new project or an agreed share of deliveries?
Do not reserve ongoing capacity based solely on approval. Ask about the required response time and agree how availability will be confirmed when the buyer actually needs a delivery. An earlier approval may also need review if the drawing or manufacturing method changes.
The quotation follow-up method helps keep the next decision visible. Record the responsible person, outstanding decision and next agreed date against the quotation or trial order.
Check whether the role fits your production
Backup-supplier work may be irregular. Find out whether it fits your setup times, material purchasing and other workload. Promising urgent work will not help if it delays deliveries you have already agreed.
Define in advance what you can offer while the rest of production is running. Building a buyer profile helps distinguish suitable recurring work from occasional RFQs that do not fit your production.
A second-source supplier role is useful when both parties understand its purpose. The machine shop demonstrates its capability through an agreed delivery, and the buyer explains when that capability may be used again.
Start with a suitable buyer
Ironspan looks for buyers whose needs fit a machine shop’s manufacturing capability and clarifies how a first delivery could fit their purchasing process. In a free capacity review, we can define the work best suited to starting an assessment of a new supplier relationship.
