A percentage alone tells you little
Utilisation is a ratio: a machine's productive hours divided by the hours in which it could have produced. Fifty-five percent sounds reasonable and eighty percent sounds good. Neither figure tells you what the difference costs.
The problem is usually the denominator. If available hours mean the entire calendar year, 8 760 hours, every single-shift machine shop looks like an emergency. If you count only hours that already had work allocated, the figure always looks good.
For a financial calculation, the useful denominator is staffed production time: hours in which the machine could run with the current shifts and staff. Within that time, an idle hour is an actual loss rather than a theoretical one.
Utilisation and OEE measure different things
Many machine shops already monitor overall equipment effectiveness, or OEE. It shows how well a machine performs when work is scheduled for it: whether it is available, runs at the target speed and produces good parts.
OEE does not tell you whether there is work in the first place. A machine may run with excellent overall equipment effectiveness on the three days a week for which it has orders and stand idle for the other two. Both figures are correct, but the utilisation measure used here also includes the idle days. The boundary of OEE's denominator is decisive: Vorne excludes time outside planned production time from OEE calculations.
On a surface-treatment line, the same difference appears as empty hangers. The line may run perfectly even if half the positions pass through the oven empty.
In this article, utilisation means exactly this: the proportion of staffed production time in which the machine does billable work.
The formula: three figures
You need three figures. They are all available from your own systems or can be estimated accurately enough.
1. Available hours per year. Shifts × hours per shift × production days. In a two-shift machine shop with 7.5-hour shifts and 225 production days, a machine has 3 375 available hours.
2. Productive hours. Hours you invoice: metal is cut, sheet is bent or setup is performed for an order the customer pays for. Sources are covered in more detail below.
3. Contribution margin per productive hour. The machine-hour price paid by the customer, less the hour's variable costs: energy, cutting tools, coolant and wearing parts. Material is excluded because it is a separate line in the quotation.
These give two different figures, and both are worth calculating:
- Lost contribution margin = (target hours – productive hours) × contribution margin per hour
- Fixed cost per productive hour = the machine's fixed annual costs ÷ productive hours
The first tells you how much is forgone. The second tells you how much every sold hour must carry.
Target hours are calculated by multiplying available hours by the utilisation rate the machine could realistically achieve. How to set that target is discussed below.
Example calculation: a five-axis machining centre
Financing the machining centre costs 2 800 € per month, or 33 600 € per year. Premises, maintenance, software licences and insurance add 9 400 €. Fixed costs therefore total 43 000 € per year, whether the machine runs or not.
The machine runs in two shifts, giving 3 375 available hours. The machine-hour price is 78 € and variable costs are 17 € per hour, so each productive hour leaves a contribution margin of 61 €.
| Example machine | Utilisation 55% | Utilisation 80% |
|---|---|---|
| Productive hours per year | 1 856 h | 2 700 h |
| Annual contribution margin | 113 216 € | 164 700 € |
| Fixed cost per productive hour | 23.17 € | 15.93 € |
The difference is about 51 500 € in contribution margin per year from one machine — provided the missing 844 hours could have been sold. This condition is the core of the issue, and we return to it below.
The second figure is less obvious. At 55 percent utilisation, each sold hour must cover 23.17 € in fixed costs; at 80 percent, 15.93 €. The difference, 7.24 € per hour, appears in either your quotation prices or your margin.
The same formula for a press brake
The formula is not limited to machining. A single-shift press brake has 1 687.5 available hours (7.5 h × 225 days). At 45% utilisation, it produces about 759 productive hours.
With a contribution margin of 44 € per hour and a realistic utilisation target of 70 percent, the gap is about 422 hours. The lost contribution margin is therefore about 18 600 € per year. The sum is smaller than for the machining centre, but the calculation is exactly the same.
In bending, setup mainly means changing tools and measuring the first part. If setup is not invoiced separately, it is not counted as productive, even if the press is running throughout.
Why underutilisation has no expense line
The income statement has lines for financing, wages, energy and premises. Each is paid whether the machine runs or not. There is no line for an idle hour because it is not an expense but missing income.
That makes underutilisation difficult to notice. The budget is compared with the previous year rather than capacity: if revenue stayed the same, the year looks stable even if the machines stood idle for a third of the time.
Another hiding place is the machine-hour price. If the price was originally calculated at 80 percent utilisation and the actual level is 55 percent, every quotation leaves some fixed costs uncovered. Nobody decides this — it happens quietly in every quotation calculation.
The third reason is the division of responsibilities. The production manager is responsible for completing jobs on time, while sales, if there is a sales function, is responsible for sending quotations. An idle machine is not the first line in anyone's metrics, so it falls between everyone's figures.
Reliable sources for productive hours
Modern CNC controls record spindle running time and program durations. The figure is precise, but it does not separate setup, trial runs or rejected parts.
For welding robots and cells, the corresponding figure is arc-on time, usually available in the power source or robot controller log. For manual welding, the most reliable source is the job card.
ERP job cards show which order the hour was spent on, but only if the cards are completed carefully. Take the same month from both sources and compare the figures — the difference helps show which source is reliable.
If there are no systems, a two-week log beside the machine is enough: start time, end time and order number. The log is approximate, but it is better than an estimate given over coffee.
Before calculating, decide whether setup time counts as productive. From a financial perspective, the rule is simple: an hour is productive if it is invoiced.
What is a good utilisation rate?
There is no single correct figure. Small batches and frequently changing products involve a high share of setup, so utilisation is naturally lower than in long production runs.
The direction matters more than the level. If utilisation has fallen for three consecutive quarters, the cause is rarely the machine.
Why a fully loaded machine is not the goal
High utilisation is not all positive. As a machine approaches full load, a queue forms in front of it, and the queue grows much faster than utilisation rises.
A simple queueing model illustrates the effect. Waiting time relative to processing time is utilisation divided by the unused proportion: at 50 percent the multiplier is 1, at 80 percent it is 4, at 90 percent it is 9 and at 95 percent it is 19.
The model is an M/M/1 queue: one service point, independent random arrivals and exponentially distributed service times. The multiplier is the ratio of mean queueing time to mean service time. Machine shop batches, setups and job sequencing do not, as such, meet these assumptions. Source: MIT, M/M/1 Queue (PDF).
The figures are not a forecast for any machine shop, but the pattern holds: the last percentage points are paid for in lead time. Lead time often determines the winner of a quotation competition, so an overloaded machine loses quotations before price is even discussed.
A fully loaded machine also has no room for a rush order, and rush orders often command the best prices. A sensible target comes from your own figures: how many hours are needed as a flexibility buffer and what is the contribution margin per hour?
Utilisation before investing in a machine
Make the same calculation before ordering a new machine. A new machine brings fixed costs immediately, but productive hours only after work has been sold for it.
The break-even point is found by dividing the machine's fixed annual costs by the contribution margin per hour. The result is the number of productive hours the machine must run each year to cover the fixed annual costs used in the calculation. This is the threshold for covering annual costs, not the investment payback period.
The threshold is 60 000 € ÷ 65 €, or about 923 productive hours per year. A single shift has 1 687.5 available hours, so the calculation's fixed annual costs are covered at about 55 percent utilisation.
If the existing machines already run below this level, a new machine does not help. It adds fixed costs that the same workload must cover and moves the question where it belongs: is there enough work for the existing machines?
Three ways to raise utilisation — and when they do not help
Shorter setups. Zero-point clamping, preset tools and standardised programs free up hours. If the bottleneck is demand rather than the machine, a shorter setup simply increases idle time because the same workload takes fewer hours.
Flexible pricing for available capacity. A lower hourly price offered during quiet periods brings work, because every hour that leaves a contribution margin is better than an idle hour. The risk is that the customer learns to expect the same price during busy periods too.
More demand. When a machine stands idle because there is no work, only new orders help. Orders often arrive fastest from customers who have bought before and then gone quiet without explanation.
It is easiest for a new buyer to say yes when they are not asked to replace their current supplier. Start the search for completely new buyers with your own machine list.
If utilisation fell because one large customer reduced its orders, the issue is different: customer concentration risk.
Calculate your own figure
Fill in the rows separately for each machine. A workshop average hides the fact that one machine may run at full load while another stands idle half the time.
| Row | What to enter | Your figure |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Shifts × hours per shift × production days = available hours | ____ h |
| 2 | Productive hours over the last 12 months | ____ h |
| 3 | Utilisation = row 2 ÷ row 1 | ____ % |
| 4 | Contribution margin per productive hour = machine-hour price – variable costs | ____ € |
| 5 | Utilisation the machine could realistically achieve | ____ % |
| 6 | Lost contribution margin = (row 5 – row 3) × row 1 × row 4 | ____ € / year |
| 7 | Fixed cost per productive hour = fixed annual costs ÷ row 2 | ____ € / h |
Row 6 is a figure many machine shops see for the first time. Row 7 shows whether your machine-hour price was calculated using actual or hoped-for utilisation.
How to monitor the figure
Calculate utilisation by machine once a month and review a three-month moving average. Individual months vary with holidays and large batches; the average shows the direction.
Utilisation describes the past. The order book — hours already confirmed but not yet worked — describes the future: when the order book shortens, utilisation follows a few weeks later.
Track the two figures together. When the order book begins to shorten, there is still time to respond through sales — once utilisation has fallen, that time has been used.
Three questions after the calculation
Is underutilisation constant or seasonal? If machines stand idle every summer and before Christmas, the issue is the rhythm of demand, which calls for a different response from year-round idle time.
Is it one machine or all of them? If one machine stands idle and the others run, the question is whether buyers can be found for that machine's specific capability. If all stand idle, the question concerns the whole workshop's sales.
Do you know who could buy the idle hours? This is the hardest question, and the answer is usually no. The calculation shows what underutilisation costs, but not where the missing orders will come from.
Once you have calculated the figure
If the figure in row 6 is larger than you expected, the next question is where you can sell the hours in the gap.
Ironspan finds new buyers for machine shops and brings technically qualified RFQs to the table. Commission is paid only on actual orders. In a free capacity review, we go through the machine list and utilisation in two hours.
